The OMS RFP Template

Build an OMS RFP that evaluates operational outcomes, not feature lists.

Most OMS evaluations focus on functionality. The best buying teams evaluate implementation speed, workflow flexibility, fulfillment capabilities, integration architecture, and long-term operational ownership.

This template helps you compare vendors against the criteria that matter after go-live.

Download the OMS RFP Template Preview the framework
Free download · editable RFP document · vendor scoring workbook · built for enterprise order operations teams
The evaluation framework

Most OMS evaluations over-index on features

Feature parity is common across OMS platforms. The bigger differences typically appear in implementation timelines, operational flexibility, integration complexity, and the ability to adapt as business requirements evolve.

A strong OMS evaluation should help answer
How quickly can we deploy?
How much IT involvement is required to maintain workflows?
How easily can we add channels, fulfillment locations, and new business models?
How well does the platform support future operational complexity?

The goal is not simply to buy software. The goal is to build an operational foundation that scales with the business.

Traditional OMS Evaluation
×Focuses heavily on feature checklists
×Prioritizes module breadth
×Relies on implementation services for customization
×Often requires middleware for key integrations
×Makes operational changes dependent on technical resources
Modern OMS Evaluation
Focuses on operational outcomes
Prioritizes adaptability and speed
Enables business-led workflow management
Supports native integrations and automation
Allows operations teams to move quickly as requirements change
OMS evaluation categories

Eight areas every OMS RFP should cover

The template organizes requirements into eight categories commonly used by retailers, brands, distributors, and enterprise commerce teams evaluating order management platforms. Each category includes sample requirements, evaluation guidance, and scoring criteria.

01
Order Routing
Evaluate how effectively the platform determines where and how orders should be fulfilled.
4 requirements
Multi-location order routing
Rules-based fulfillment logic
Inventory-aware sourcing
Automated exception handling
Key considerationCan the platform optimize fulfillment decisions across cost, speed, inventory availability, and operational constraints?
02
Inventory & Available-to-Sell
Evaluate inventory visibility and inventory allocation capabilities.
4 requirements +
03
Fulfillment Operations
Evaluate support for modern fulfillment models.
4 requirements +
04
Returns & Post-Purchase Operations
Evaluate post-purchase flexibility and customer experience support.
4 requirements +
05
Integrations
Evaluate connectivity across the commerce ecosystem.
4 requirements +
06
Data, Security & Compliance
Evaluate governance, visibility, and compliance capabilities.
4 requirements +
07
Business User Experience
Evaluate operational usability.
4 requirements +
08
Support & Implementation
Evaluate deployment and ongoing support.
4 requirements +
Vendor scoring framework

Create a consistent evaluation process across stakeholders

The included scoring workbook lets operations, ecommerce, IT, customer experience, and leadership teams evaluate vendors using the same criteria. Each category is weighted by business importance and scored using a structured framework.

1 Manual or heavily customized

The capability requires significant customization, services engagement, or manual processes.

3 Supported with tradeoffs

The capability is supported but may require configuration, integration work, or operational tradeoffs.

5 Native and business-led

The capability is fully supported through native functionality and can be managed directly by the business.

Weighted scoring The workbook automatically calculates weighted scores and supports side-by-side vendor comparisons.
Get the toolkit

Download the OMS RFP Toolkit

Receive the complete toolkit used to evaluate order management platforms. Enter your work email and we will send it instantly. No sales call required.

Editable OMS RFP template
Vendor scoring workbook
Evaluation framework across 8 categories
Stakeholder review guide
Sample scoring methodology
Get instant access
Three quick fields and the toolkit is on its way.
By downloading you agree to receive occasional order operations insights from Pipe17. Unsubscribe anytime.

Make a more informed OMS decision

Use a structured evaluation framework to compare vendors, align stakeholders, and select a platform that supports long-term operational growth.

Download the OMS RFP Toolkit